![]() |
Association of African Universities
Association des Universités Africaines |
| Welcome/
Bienvenue
|
(DATAD) IMPROVING MANAGEMENT AND ACCESS TO AFRICAN SCHOLARLY WORK: DATABASE OF AFRICAN THESES AND DISSERTATIONS DATAD WORKSHOP REPORT
DATAD WORKSHOP REPORT I: OPENING The Chairman of the session, Dr. Asrat Worku welcomed the workshop participants and invited the DATAD Coordinator Ms. Mary Materu-Behitsa to give a brief background of the project and the workshop. She explained the objectives of the workshop, which were to discuss issues and challenges encountered in the implementation process and forge the way forward. She gave a brief history of the project explaining that DATAD is an AAU project that is partially funded by Ford and Rockefeller Foundations. The main aim of DATAD, is to develop a comprehensive research database and put to the world the research output from the continent of Africa. She noted the dedication of the management of Addis Ababa University
to the project and acknowledged their contribution towards the organization
of the workshop. Eleven institutions were involved in the DATAD process
and were all represented in the workshop. The Project coordinator acknowledged
the dedication of some participants who were on transit for days due to
weather problems and ended by inviting participants to visit the AAU website
for more information on the initiative (http://www.aau.org/datad/).
The Opening Address The Guest of Honor, the Academic Vice President for Addis Ababa University,
Dr. Butte Gottu, in his Opening Address noted the challenges faced by higher
education institutions in Africa as characterized by more information flow
and traffic from outside as compared to what goes out and lack of concerted
internal efforts of collecting, organizing and disseminating information
on ongoing research in Africa. He urged for the need to put in place strategies
to address the problem. He also observed and acknowledged the formation
of AAU in 1967 as part of the strategies to arrest the problem as reflected
in its main objectives which is to collect, organize and disseminate information
and research in Africa and networking among its members. He commended the
inception of DATAD in 2000, which is currently having a number of institutions
participating at a pilot stage aimed at disseminating research information
from Africa. He touched on the issue of copyright and the need to develop
update copyright policies, as one of the highly debated areas in higher
institutions. He urged participants in the workshop and institutions to
seek for solutions these and other related issues. He ended by commending
the commitment of the participants and their institutions and wished the
initiative all the success for the pilot to grow into a comprehensive program.
With these remarks, he declared to workshop open. (Full
address )
Vote of thanks In response, Ms. Dorcas Kigozi (DATAD Coordinator, Makerere University)
acknowledged the issues raised by Prof. Butte, especially lack of visibility
of African research output in the world mainstream of knowledge. She further
challenged AAU and participating institutions to see to it that the project
survives and succeeds by continuing to give guidance and mobilizing the
rest of African Universities to come together and build a comprehensive
research tool in Africa, from Africa, by Africans.
II: WORKING SESSIONS Session 1 1. Trouble shooting with Procite and Reference Web Poster The trouble shooting exercise intended to cover issues and problems that participants had been experiencing in using the software packages provided for the project and share any innovative solutions they had come up with. Mr Benjamin A. Eshun the AAU-DATAD ICT expert took the group through the workings of Procite and addressed problems thereof. A brief overview of Procite was provided with details about the DATAD Work Form and fields. The additional field of "alternate abstract", which was introduced, as a response to the bilingual needs of YaoundeI (Cameroon) was noted to be catering for the bilingual needs of institutions. The table of contents field was explained as a request from Makerere. It was discussed and participants agreed that its inclusion was optional. The DATAD identifier field was explained as a domain of AAU. The Procite global update feature was mentioned and planned to be discussed and shown in the later parts of the planned program hands on experience. This part was planned for after workshop hours for more troubleshooting. The length of abstracts was raised and discussed. It was agreed that abstracts should be included as they appear in the documents and the software is capable of handling long abstracts so editing should only be for spellings. Agreed further that for documents with no abstracts provided, they should generate one - provided there is capacity to do so. In order to speed the process participants agreed to complete those with abstracts first. Participants also agreed to use academic departments to help with abstract generation/writing. The introduction of a gender field was raised and explained. After discussions
it was agreed to maintain the gender field in the DATAD record. It was
noted that DATAD is more than a bibliographic description of items. The
need to capture information that can be used for other purposes was explained
and accepted. It was discussed at length and accepted that it has to be
well explained in the introduction to the DATAD database to avoid mis-interpretation
of possible statistics that may be generated as the database may not be
a true representative of gender patterns for higher education provisions
in Africa. Participants agreed that efforts will be made to include exhaustively
the postgraduate work done at all levels.
2. Trouble shooting with Omni Page Pro 11
Session 2 The DATAD Methodology Manual
DATAD-Procite Workform
The Manual provides Broad Subject Categories and Guideline for personal author names as Appendices. It was recommended to have more African names as examples. The contributions by participants institutions was acknowledged and the presentation was concluded by a re-assurance that issues raised will be addressed in the final draft as recommended. Session 3 Visit to Addis Ababa University
DAY 2 The second day concentrated on paper presentations and reports from the institutions. Session 1 The Chairperson for the morning session was Mr. Felix Ubogu. He invited
the participants, announced the change of programme and plans to complete
the morning session by 1.00 p.m. The morning programme began with introduction
of participants - each member introduced her/himself. Members gave their
names, place of work, what they do and their connection with DATAD.
Paper presentations
The paper highlighted the situation at many institutions in Africa: not well financed research, university student research output housed in restricted collections, little research information emanating from Africa. He noted the potential for ICT to reverse the trend through the use of campus networks and the Internet. The search for efficient and flexible access was observed as one of the reason for building digital collections as it solves time constraints and bridges geographical distances. He took the participants through the concepts of digitization and electronic publishing, emphasizing that digitization projects need to be based on clear objectives, goals, and well-defined functions and processes. On full text digitization, the paper notes the challenges posed by hard disk space and special software requirements, standards and access restrictions. He further explained that implementing a digital project requires a policy framework as much as institutional computing and network infrastructure for the implementers and the users of the system. Adding that standards and guidelines need to be taken into account in relation to data storage (proprietary formats), data description formats, and guidelines for selection content, issues of digital archiving and disaster recovery. Data archiving, preservation and the need to document all the project decisions and process for future reference was emphasized. Ms. Materu-Behitsa presented a case study of the lead paper, on DATAD. She provided the main background on how the DATAD was conceived, structured, financed, fairing and going on and future plans. Eleven institutions are participating in the project. On DATAD resource development model, DATAD is using both centralized and decentralized models. Rationale for the choice of Procite software was provided. Lines of communication and division of responsibilities were explained as well as where the DATAD project has reached so far. Project Monitoring and Evaluation procedures were also explained. Ms Materu-Behitsa noted that the DATAD process is well documented at all levels and though the project is donor funded it enjoys full support from AAU Secretariat. She explained that from the beginning the aim was to make the project institutional owned. So far the trend shows all participating institutions are willing but most institutions are very cautious of the question of issuing full text documents. She noted that data integrity and credibility goes beyond the digitization process, therefore institution were urged to put up mechanisms to facilitate accessibility in terms of having relevant access policies and guidelines in place. The future of DATAD and issues for discussion as presented mainly centered on pushing forward the main objectives of DATAD to include strategies for utilizing DATAD as a tool for research and information generation as well as communication and networking. The number of institutions to be invited each year was expected to be scaled up. Among other things that need to be addressed included responding to purchase requests of theses indexed in DATAD, full text submission of theses and dissertations within the participating institutions, backup and preservation policy for participating institutions and the Coordinating unit. The chairperson called upon participants to discuss the papers. Observed that issues for discussions were given and the chairperson started the discussion by asking participants to give their experiences on how do they respond to a full text requests for theses from their collections. CODESRIA shared their experiences in handling such requests. The requesting party is made to sign a special form showing the conditions for use of the document. For the University of Ghana, a policy of copyright is not yet available and thesis photocopying is not allowed. One has to get permission from the Author or the Dean of the Faculty where the thesis emanated. For Addis Ababa, they are in the process of developing a copyright policy with the relevant departments. At Makerere, a maximum of one third photocopying is allowed. The policy for full text is yet to be worked out. Given the status at the different institutions, it was noted that individuals and institutions should speed up the process for having clear policies as it is likely that when DATAD goes online, requests for full text from Africa and other parts of the world will increase. It is therefore important for intellectual property rights to be made clear and understood so as to come to a level of an understanding as to what to do in case a request comes through. Generally it was observed that for DATAD, copyright/statements will differ from one institution to the other due to differences in background. Each institution should therefore discuss internally and come out with a statement on the access policy for its database. On electronic submissions, it was proposed to study practices on successful
initiatives, and the following sites may provide useful informatin: http://etguide.org/,
http://www.lib.uwaterloo.ca/ETD/reports.html,
http://www.library.unsw.edu.au/thesis/thesis.html
Other issues § As the DATAD project has been operating on invitation, The Association of African Universities was requested to work out guidelines for other institutions which may want to join DATAD. The need to encourage students to submit an electronic version of their thesis with their hard copy was encouraged. § In ensuring DATAD meets its targeted pilot project submission participants agreed to come up with a realistic timetable to submit around 2000 records from each institution as the pilot DATAD project is running for only 3 years (February 2000 - February 2003). The need for all records to be sent in before the end of the first phase was emphasized. Participants were informed that all responsible parties - AAU and DATAD - AAU will need to start discussions with Ford and Rockefeller Foundations to seek for additional support as early as six months before the end of this pilot. Participants accepted that there was a need for a backup and preservation policy for each DATAD participating institution. III: REPORTS FROM INSTITUTIONS Report from Makerere University The report was presented by the DATAD Coordinator, Mrs Dorcas Kigozi . She reported that training took place for 2 days in January 2002 and
3 people were trained. Makerere collection has 3,002 theses and dissertations.
Problems/Challenges faced ACRONYM - University names kept on changing, from the East African University
to Makerere University. Problems with scanning whereby theses submitted
on flimsy paper or carbon copied could not be scanned. Copyright statement
was still being formulated, a copy of which was presented.(Makerere
Report)
Report from University of Zimbabwe The presentation was made by Mrs Caroline Rioga, the Coordinator for
University of Zimbabwe. She reported that DATAD Management Team was established.
The team received training and is responsible for the day-to-day work of
the project. The management team has members from various relevant departments
and this operates as an advisory team/body.
On February 2002 computer science students were hired to do data input
and are paid by the University. There are 545 records in the database and
the whole collection has 2,500 theses and dissertations.
Institutional Support Staff support, in the form of professional librarians, paraprofessionals (students), ICT staff are highly involved in the project.
Other activities Indexes of various theses on hard copies but these have some limitations,
for example abstracts are truncated and some have no keywords.
Copyright statement This was based on the Zimbabwe Copyright Act of 1981. The process for
a specific policy for the institution is in the process.
Problems/challenges
Report from Yaounde1 University Yaounde1 University presentation was made by Professor Edward Ako. Yaounde1 has 10 members in the management team. The Rector is the Chairperson of the DATAD Management Team. Training was done in February 2002 and was well received by participants who indicated satisfaction with the training and skills they obtained. For them indexing started with the long essays (but these will not be forwarded to DATAD). Most of their records were already in CDS/ISIS and these can be converted to Procite. Though this process of conversion is going on it is still slow. Challenges
Alarmed by the low pace of data entry, participants were asked to roughly commit themselves as to how many records each institution can produce for AAU by 15th November 2002. The following were the responses: Makerere - 1000 to 1200; CODESRIA - 700; Mozambique - 1000 Zimbabwe - 1200 Senegal - 2000+ Tanzania - 2000 Participants were requested to think along these lines and provide a commitment in terms of realistic numbers and abide by it. On the question of which ACRONYMN to use Makerere was advised to use both the old name and new/current name e.g. old//new; entered in that order. For thesis that was submitted at an institution from outside their own but a copy is deposited at their institution then the Acronym for the University where thesis was submitted need to appear. Inclusion of table of content was left at each institutions discretion. It was also noted this can be done at a later stage The idea of a quarterly issue of DATAD Newsletter was raised and accepted. Participants were reminded of their responsibility in ensuring their contribution to the newsletter (articles etc.) Yaounde1: Problems associated conversion of CDS/ISIS databases. It was noted that it was possible but the process was tedious and time consuming. (see appendix for full report) Report from Addis Ababa University The report was presented by Million Meshesha. The collection totaled 2,153 with 2,102 in English language and 51 in Amharic language. Data entry was organized in three steps: Scanning, indexing and finalizing. Three people were involved in the task and one individual was responsible for each part. Most of the entries in the database have undergone the first and second
part of functions (scanning and indexing) at the time of reporting. By
15 November 2002 there will be 2000 + records in the Addis DATAD Project
Database and each dissertation/thesis will have a Catalogue/Call number.
Contribution of the University The University has offered office facilities, manpower and overtime for workers who work during the weekends. Challenges: - conversion of the Aphasic language theses and provision of keywords. Future plans Possibility of standardized thesis format from each department. (Addis
Ababa Report)
Report from Université Cheikh Anta Diop de Dakar (UCAD) - Senegal The initiation of the project took place in February 2002 during the visit by the DATAD Coordinator. Indexing began in April 2002. By 4th June 2002, 932 records had been indexed. There are 5116 theses in the collection at the Central Library of the University. The DATAD Management Team was formed and consists of members from faculties. Technical Team was also set up for the day-to-day follow-up and working
of the project. The Director of the 'Institute Fondamental D'Afrique Noire(IFAN)
at UCAD is the Coordinator of the project. UCAD has adequate and qualified
human resources to do the work. Will have 2000 records for DATAD project
report by November 15th.
Institutional Support The University bodies at all levels ensured clean and smooth clearance
and delivery of the equipment for the project. Human resources in the form
of Librarians and ICT personnel have been involved in working on the project.
Students have also been recruited to produce abstracts that are not more
than 250 words. A special room in the Library has been reserved for the
project.
Other related activities The Faculty of Medicine undertakes a similar activity of producing dissertation abstracts. Challenges Problems of abstracting and a proposal for the project to provide grants
for students to undertake the work (Cheikh
Anta Diop Report)
CODESRIA Theses and dissertations are deposited at CODESRIA from various African Universities. These theses are a product of recipients of CODESRIA scholarships. These have been processed and are in a database. A total of 792 theses are in the collection and already in the database. Equipment received were a CD-Writer, a Scanner, OmnipagePro, and Procite. Other related activities to DATAD were reported as an online bibliographic database that generates catalogues and indexes. Problems: Lack of a designated office and furniture for the project;
CD writer not working from the very beginning; scanner problems similar
to those raised by other institutions $2 per thesis too low given the need
to abstract a number of theses. Copyright policy not available. These come
from all over therefore impossible to come up with one policy. (CODESRIA
Report)
Discussion after the three presentations
§ Discussions centred mainly on the UCAD (Senegal) proposal to provide grants for students who will work on the DATAD project specifically for the thesis processing. It noted that this will not be possible within the project budget and that the DATAD project was basically a capacity building initiative. In this spirit, the AAU support was not meant to cover every expense on the project. It was recommended to involve university staff so that the skills gained in the process would be useful for the sustainability of the DATAD initiative.Session 2 Chairperson: Prof E. Ako Three DATAD report from institutions, the Coordinator's report Mr. Felix
Ubogu paper on ETD's in Africa and South Africa in particular were presented.
Report from Eduardo Mondlane University (UEM)- Mozambique This was presented in Portuguese by Carlos Zimba and interpreted by Mrs Eliana Munguambe, the Coordinator for UEM. UEM has a total of 1291 theses/dissertations to be indexed. The site
had problems caused by the change of Coordinator who was the only person
fully informed of the workings of DATAD at UEM. Other problems reported
were that abstracts were truncated and edited; no clear handing over notes
to the new appointed Coordinator. Some of the challenges faced by the Mozambican
colleagues were basically based on the limited human resources and lack
of information on the DATAD project given the change of a Coordinator.
They had no copyright policy and most of their database records were already
in ISIS. This made conversion very slow.
However the Coordinator for Mozambique promised that by November 15th
they would have 2000 edited records at AAU-DATAD. AAU-DATAD had to work
closely with the new Coordinator to fill in the gaps. The need to assist
Mozambique was noted and possibility of the team to visit neighbouring
country or for a day to be trained was suggested. Options were left open
for the two presenters to decide. It was made clear that AAU-DATAD will
not be able to send someone in Mozambique in the near future. (UEM
Report)
Report from University of Dar es Salaam (UDSM), Tanzania The project preparations took place by forming a project management
team in 2001, equipment delivery was done and training done by December
2001. Informed that the University of Dar es Salaam has 3 campuses. The
main Campus two for its constituent colleges: College of Lands and Architectural
Studies and College of Medicine. DATAD project is situated at the Main
Campus library. The Main Library has about 4000 theses in place. This number
did not did not include those from its constituent colleges. So far the
DATAD database has 1,275 records indexed out of which 500 records have
been edited and put into a CD.
UDSM DATAD project will deliver the 2000 records fully edited to the
AAU-DATAD by November 2002. Other related activities undertaken at the
University of Dar es Salaam were briefly explained notably, the LIBIS (the
main catalogue), specilized databases, eg BIODIVERSITY and ENVIRONMENTAL
databases, the NYERERE databases collection, and several Tanzania regional
bibliographies. These were reported to have complemented the work of DATAD
to a great extent.
On the contribution of UDSM to DATAD it was reported that this was evident
in the number of staff time across all levels chipping in to DATAD work.
The presence of a pool of staff qualified in ICT has made a big difference
in tackling DATAD project. More equipment i.e. two extra computers have
been made available to facilitate the work. (UDSM
Report)
Report from University of Ghana, Legon Equipment was delivered. Have a total of 2810 theses in the collection
of which 1081 are carbon typed. Have a management team, which is not very
active. Library staff is assisting in the project e.g. cataloguing staff.
Equipment is housed in n air-conditioned room with LAN facility. The project
has a blessing of the institution.
Challenges:
§ Theses from carbon copies are hard to scan.
Discussions after the three presentations Participants were urged to put in place mechanisms that will ensure
continuity of the DATAD projects. Documentation of the project to ensure
staffing taking over will proceed smoothly. The importance of training
more people at various centers of DATAD projects was emphasized in order
to avoid problems emanating from staff mobility and transfers. Suggested
for universities with library schools to involved student in data input.
On sending records (500) periodically was observed to be expensive on
the participating institutions. Advised AAU to get in touch with DHL and
ask the possibility of their accepting payment in Ghana and not in country
of origin.
On the carbon paper products, Ghana was advised to photocopy the abstracts
and then scan the photocopy.
A recommendation was passed that anyone of the coordinators transferred
need to inform the DATAD Coordinator at AAU. Emphasis was placed on the
point that we are all responsible to inform all the parties we are working
with for smooth implementation of the project.
Issue of sending a limited number of indexed records was raised and
recommended that advance payments cannot be met. Payments will only be
done upon receipt of the CDs. And these have to be well-edited error free
CDs of 500 records in each CD.
Another recommendation was passed that those Universities that have
Library schools can come to an agreement to train some of the students
to do the work for DATAD.
For the typed abstracts, it was recommended to photocopy abstract before
they are scanned. It was also recommended to develop a list of participating
institutions to exchange ideas. This was reported to be already in place.
DATAD Project Coordinator's Report The project inception and the content status of the project were presented
and the remaining activities for completion of the project were also presented.
Also included were the experiences and lessons that have been learnt
so far. Noted that a lot of work entails pioneering, thinking and commitment.
She pointed out the remaining activities as mostly centered on the full
retrospective data entry, completion of the design of the AAU server and
DATAD home page, production of the CD-ROM and the DATAD database. Activities
for publicizing and marketing the database. Major challenges lies with
the issue of ownership data integrity and credibility. This she called
on her colleagues to join efforts to ensure we overcome the challenges
and make the project a success to avoid DATAD joining the syndrome of projects
that were never sustained.
Reported that DATAD pilot project funding is coming to end by February
2003. Plans are underway to work on a proposal to seek for funds to address
issues for the second phase. This will also depend on each institution
commitment to deliver on time, quality records to be able to present future
fund solicitation with integrity. Mary basically explained "Where we started,
where we are and where we are going". (Coordinators
Report)
Electronic Thesis and Dissertations (ETDs) in South Africa Mr Felix Ubogu made a brief presentation on ETDS in South Africa. He
explained the current education changes sweeping South Africa including
proposals to merge the 23 universities and 15 Technicons to a smaller manageable
number and avoid duplications of efforts and resources were revisited.
Explained that Rhodes and Pretoria University dissertations abstracts are
on the Internet. He explained the ETD scene generally in Africa and South
Africa in particular. Various projects under way in South Africa such as
SEALS, SABINET Online, COSALC and their constraints were presented. He
suggested a way forward for academic institutions in ETD projects.
Observed and revisited the point raised by Mr. Chisenga earlier on that
during preparations, theses, dissertations are produced in word processors
but at handing in, only hardcopies are handed in. Called on the need for
institutions to tap on that resource and make the ETD efforts easier to
accomplish. Presented briefly on the UNESCO manual for ETD (http://etguide.org/).
Participant appreciated the emergence of ETD as a way forward for higher
education institutions in Africa urged AAU within DATAD to initiate its
implementation within its constituency.
IV: CLOSING The project coordinator thanked all participants and extended special
thanks to Lisbeth Levey who conceived DATAD during the finalization of
an earlier CD-ROM project. The CD-ROM project introduced seven Research
Libraries in Africa into different CD-ROM databases and did evaluation
of the African Content in the same. The evaluation revealed the glaring
absence of African research output in international databases, coming up
with the DATAD initiative. She acknowledged the contribution by Lisbeth
as the initiator of DATAD and thanked her for the work. With these remarks
Dr. Asrat Hailu was invited to close the workshop.
Closing Remarks In his Closing Remarks Dr. Asrat explained the new developments at Addis
Ababa University especially the new perspectives in the management of academic
programs with the Research and Graduate Office being the focal point for
two major academic undertakings of AAU: the Graduate Studies and Research
Programs the host for DATAD at Addis Ababa University. He re-iterated the
interest by Addis Ababa University to enhance DATAD and further pioneer
ETDs, and noted that the DATAD project had demonstrated to be more than
an experimental model. He noted the issues requiring follow-up action,
namely procedures and training needs for ETDs, policy matters on Copyright
and intellectual property rights and archival modalities. (Closing
Address)
WORKSHOP OBSERVATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS The Workshop OBSERVED:
|
| Last updated: 7th October 2002 |
|
Tel: +233-21-774495/761588 Fax:+233-21-774821 email: info@aau.org |